Citi retail banking/card reorganization illustrates importance of having strategy and structure in synch

An article in Dow Jones Newswires yesterday reported that Citi has reorganized its U.S. retail banking and credit card operations, in order to improve sales and service.  The reorganization is based around customer segments, product development, and distribution.  In announcing the reorganization, Citi acknowledged that its previous structure was too product-centric.

In recent years, banks have emphasized their renewed focus on relationship banking.  These banks are now starting to understand that, to achieve their vision of relationship optimization, strategy and structure need to be in synch.  Benefits of having customer-based organizational structure:

  • The company has a much greater ability to anticipate, and react to, changes in the marketplace
  • Customer ownership rules are more clearly delineated
  • Product development starts from the perspective of the customer rather than the product
  • Employee compensation is based on the attainment of customer-focused metrics (acquisition, retention, lifetime value), rather than reaching sales goals for products that may adversely affect long-term relationships
  • Sales teams become more specialized around different segments, develop a more holistic understanding of customer needs, and can present more comprehensive solutions.  Training and sales support are also recast to focus on segments rather than products

Bank deposit growth trends

American Banker (www.americanbanker.com, subscription needed to access) recently published end-second quarter 2010 deposit data for the top 200 bank holding companies in the U.S.  These top 200 banks grew deposits by 2.9% between 2Q09 and 2Q10.  This growth rate represents a slowdown relative to recent quarters, as many banks’ need to aggressively grow deposits as a funding source has abated (loan-to-deposit ratios have fallen below 100% and loan demand is expected to remain relatively anemic).  The top 10 banks grew deposits by 1.7%.

What is most notable in the data in the continued strong deposits growth rates for leading direct (branchless) banks, including:

  • ING Direct: 17th largest bank by deposits; 4%year-over-year growth
  • Charles Schwab: 25th largest bank; 43%growth
  • USAA: 31st largest bank; 17%growth
  • Discover: 33rd largest bank; 19% growth
  • American Express: 34th largest bank; 29%growth
  • Ally Financial: 35th largest bank; 31%growth
  • MetLife: 69th largest bank; 25%growth
  • Scottrade Bank: 105th largest bank; 71%growth

Financial marketing spend continues to recover

Third-quarter financial data released by the large U.S. banks this week pointed to the continuation of a trend observed in the previous quarter: year-on-year growth in marketing spend. Marketing represents a leading indicator for banks, as it is one of the first expense categories to be hit at the start of a downturn. The corollary is that an increase in marketing spend is indicative of banks’ expectation that economic conditions are improving.

The following are changes in marketing spend for leading financial institutions between 3Q09 and 3Q10 (quarterly changes are not generally regarded as reliable, due to seasonal factors):

  • Huntington: +152%
  • Capital One: +140%
  • American Express: +68%
  • Discover: +68%
  • Chase: +48%
  • PNC: +40%
  • SunTrust: + 13%
  • Key: +11%
  • Wells Fargo: +6%
  • Bank of America: +6%
  • U.S. Bank: -21% (although note that U.S. Bank 3Q09 marketing spend was much higher than usual, due to the launch of a number of marketing initiatives)